The announcement that the new Secretary-General of the United Nations will be Antonio Guterres of Portugal brings to an end a process which has been more transparent than ever (as it included such innovations as a public debate between declared candidates). However, despite the credentials of the new Secretary-General and his laudable intentions for the organisation, his selection has highlighted the continued deficiencies in the process.
The widespread anticipation that the next Secretary-General would be the first woman in the position has been disappointed, as has been the also widespread supposition that the candidate should come from Eastern Europe, a regional grouping from which a Secretary-General has not come before. However, it is less surprising that these expectations were disappointed than at first might be thought. UN insiders, including both member states and activists engaged with the organisation, informally imposed both regional and gender criteria, creating a steep gradient against which potential candidates who did not satisfy these demographic requirements had to climb. This inevitably limited the pool of strong candidates, including women candidates, who were willing to enter the race. (While two of the five finally declared women candidates were from outside Eastern Europe, many others appear to have been discouraged by the drumbeat in favour of the region – and both of those who did ultimately run were insiders whose prior UN records were viewed by many as either unremarkable or poor).
Although there were numerous potential candidates, those from Eastern Europe were generally weaker in terms of evident credentials, lacking much experience of the United Nations system or otherwise having a checkered record. Strong candidates from elsewhere were likely to have been discouraged by the drumbeat in favour of demographic criteria that did not favour them — eventuating in the notion in UN circles that the candidate should if at all possible be both a woman and from Eastern Europe. At the same time, the process remained opaque and dependent on state sponsorship and backroom power-broking. [The regional groupings are also highly unequal in terms of number of countries and their share of the world’s population — more than half of the world’s population and more than a quarter of countries are in the Asia-Pacific, while twelve percent of member states and less than five percent of the world ‘s population lives in Eastern Europe].
If the expectation had been that the candidate selected would have been a woman, without imposing a regional criterion additionally, this would surely have increased the quantity and quality of the women candidates who made themselves available globally, especially if the process had been more transparent and readily accessible to individual candidates lacking state sponsorship. (In saying so, I am not suggesting that Guterres’s qualifications accounted for his final selection over a woman candidate; the point is rather that a stronger field would have made it harder not to choose a woman). In the event, the actual outcome was that neither representativeness criterion was met.
There are three lessons, which taken together would help to reconcile the goals of representativeness and excellence.
First, it would be far better if demographic characteristics were viewed as positive attributes rather than as restrictions (this is a lesson for the campaigners as much as for officialdom). The idea that a woman candidate or one from an until now unrepresented region should be favoured is appropriate, given that the Secretary General’s role is to act as a champion for all of humanity. But the case for giving weight to these criteria could have been made publicly without imposing them as presumed requirements. Doing so would have offered more flexibility to choose the best candidate from the available pool and to ensure the quality of that pool.
Second, and relatedly, the idea of regional turn-taking for individual posts (as with regional or national “possession” of individual senior UN posts) should be put aside. The position of Secretary-General, like those of President of the World Bank, Managing Director of the IMF and other leadership positions in major international organisations, should be made open to all nationalities and chosen on the basis of relevant job related competence and experience, while giving some weight to the positive attributes of regional representation, gender balance, etc. In the case of the Bretton Woods Institutions, which have historically offered their highest role only to Americans and Europeans, such a reform is clearly in the interests of global representativeness as well as individual excellence, so there is no tradeoff at all. For that reason, the demand to widen the selection process has been the focus of growing attention.
Third, it would be far better to think of representation by region and gender in terms of the portfolio of senior positions within the United Nations system and in international organisations, instead of putting all of the weight of such considerations upon any single post. Appropriate composition of that portfolio must respond not only to the financial contributions or political influence of countries as at present but also to diffuse “democratic” criteria of different kinds, including representativeness by gender, region and population. More generally, it is best to think of the system of international organisations as well as of each individual organisation as being defined by its staff and not merely by its leadership. “Presidential” thinking has not served the UN system, which is bound up in hierarchical deference and diplomatic culture, especially well. Representation throughout the organization matters but it cannot be reduced to any single criterion nor can it be allowed to become the overarching concern that structures the search for the best candidates.
An approach based on these three principles, which can be formalized through a process defined by a more empowered International Civil Service Commission or a similar body, is likely to ensure more adequate representation of the world’s people as well as the choice of the best candidates for posts, while helping to break up the often pernicious hold of individual countries or groups of countries on individual appointments.
The international system must be driven, and must be seen to be driven, by the need to provide a high quality of leadership that delivers for people, rather than to operate on the basis of agreements brokered – for their own reasons – between insiders. A higher level of openness in such selection processes is necessary to deliver the combination of representativeness and excellence that is needed.
Despite his merits, the newly appointed Secretary-General creates the impression of having been an insiders’ candidate, who not only has the institutional experience but also speaks the language that marks him as such, notwithstanding his advocacy of a human rights agenda, stemming in part from his prior role as UN High Commissioner for Refugees. There are doubts as to the extent to which he will transform the United Nations system, as a direct consequence. One indication of this is that his “vision statement” is full of unchallenging and bureaucratic language, such as to propose to ‘fine-tune’ the ‘UN Development System’ (which I can testify, from my own role as a member of the Independent Team of Advisers to the member states in the UN’s Economic and Social Council, requires rather more than fine-tuning!). That his appointment appears from the first to owe itself to mysterious forces, in a media-driven age, has limited his credibility from the start. He will have to earn more of it from the global public if not from member-states, especially in light of the dashed “democratic” expectations of adequate regional and gender representation.
The United Nations system faces unprecedented challenges, which in its current form it is not prepared to meet. It needs radical reforms – from the very top down, giving rise to a full agenda for the UN system, the member states, and most of all the new Secretary-General.
